Big spoiler: Agent Brody ( are we suppose to like him? )

[luvthistle1]

Spoiler.........spoiler>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>


























.>.....




spoiler*******************************************************************************************************************************











I love Kerr Smith, as Agent Brody, when he first came on the show. I
also thought that he and Paige made a perfect couple...until that he
became so obsess with the avatars, that he doesn't seem to care for
anyone else, or about who he hurt in the process.
In There's Something About Leo". Brody finds out that Leo is an avatar.
he doesn't want to talk about it, or anything he just want to kill Leo,
because Leo is an avatar ( did he think Paige was going to be o.k with
that? or did he care?)

The Brody knock out Paige, held a gun to Phoebe head , and threaten to
kill her,. than he tried to kill Leo....but since the whole thing was
revease..the Charmed ones will never know...
which is information Paige needed to know, before the incident in
Witchness Protection"..in which they found out that he put sheridan in
a coma. Note- Brody said he can take her out any time he want too,..but
how? what type of coma is she in? and drug induce coma, or an magic
induce coma?

Than in "Ordinary Witches" Brody again, kills Leo, even after Paige
told him that Leo is not an threat to him, or anyone. again, time is
revease so that no one knows. spoiler*********************

Brody finds out that the avatars did not kill his parents after all,
yet he still wants to kill avatars..but the charmed ones will never
know that, because time is reset.

Than in Extreme Makeover: World Edition. Brody works with the demon
Zankou to get rid of the avatars. he even use a potion he got from
Zankou on Paige, ( which speads to all of the charmed ones) to make
them paranoid. Brody feels that killing all the demons is wrong (
althought he right, still). but since he know it was the demons who
killed his parents, it would seem like he would wants to kill all the
demons? he kills an avatar and dies...new world. the charmed ones are
still not aware that Brody did anything wrong...and to top it all off,
what do he get for putting Sheridan in a coma, knocking out his
girlfriend, threatening to kill Phoebe, and Killing Leo twice, casting
a spell/potion on the charmed ones, and working with demons?


what do he gets?!

......he gets to become a..say it with me.....he get to become.....

....A "WHITELIGHTER!"

...Yes! Agent Karl Brody is reward whitelighter status in Episode 7.14:
"Carpe Demon'

he didn't save the world, nor did he save the charmed one or the
elders...he just kill one avatar, . The charmed ones , or anyone would
ever know how crazy obsess with avatars he truely was, nor will they
ever know all the wrong he done....that time reset, really sucks.

[luvthistle1]

Post by luvthistle1
Spoiler.........spoiler>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
.>.....

spoiler*******************************************************************************************************************************

Post by luvthistle1
I love Kerr Smith, as Agent Brody, when he first came on the show. I
also thought that he and Paige made a perfect couple...until that he
became so obsess with the avatars, that he doesn't seem to care for
anyone else, or about who he hurt in the process.
In There's Something About Leo". Brody finds out that Leo is an avatar.
he doesn't want to talk about it, or anything he just want to kill Leo,
because Leo is an avatar ( did he think Paige was going to be o.k with
that? or did he care?)
The Brody knock out Paige, held a gun to Phoebe head , and threaten to
kill her,. than he tried to kill Leo....but since the whole thing was
revease..the Charmed ones will never know...
which is information Paige needed to know, before the incident in
Witchness Protection"..in which they found out that he put sheridan in
a coma. Note- Brody said he can take her out any time he want

too,..but

Post by luvthistle1
how? what type of coma is she in? and drug induce coma, or an magic
induce coma?
Than in "Ordinary Witches" Brody again, kills Leo, even after Paige
told him that Leo is not an threat to him, or anyone. again, time is
revease so that no one knows. spoiler*********************
Brody finds out that the avatars did not kill his parents after all,
yet he still wants to kill avatars..but the charmed ones will never
know that, because time is reset.
Than in Extreme Makeover: World Edition. Brody works with the demon
Zankou to get rid of the avatars. he even use a potion he got from
Zankou on Paige, ( which speads to all of the charmed ones) to make
them paranoid. Brody feels that killing all the demons is wrong (
althought he right, still). but since he know it was the demons who
killed his parents, it would seem like he would wants to kill all the
demons? he kills an avatar and dies...new world. the charmed ones are
still not aware that Brody did anything wrong...and to top it all off,
what do he get for putting Sheridan in a coma, knocking out his
girlfriend, threatening to kill Phoebe, and Killing Leo twice,

casting

Post by luvthistle1
a spell/potion on the charmed ones, and working with demons?
what do he gets?!
......he gets to become a..say it with me.....he get to become.....
....A "WHITELIGHTER!"
"Carpe Demon'
he didn't save the world, nor did he save the charmed one or the
elders...he just kill one avatar, . The charmed ones , or anyone would
ever know how crazy obsess with avatars he truely was, nor will they
ever know all the wrong he done....that time reset, really sucks.

I want to know what everyone thinks of the time reset, and Brody.
especially "Redwind"

[Red Wind]

Post by luvthistle1
I want to know what everyone thinks of the time reset, and Brody.
especially "Redwind"

Ask and ye shall recieve...

Personally, I don't like the idea of Brody being made a Whitelighter. As it
stands, I don't think he deserves it, but I am willing to see what reason
the show gives for the Elders making him one. As far as the time reset
goes, the Elders should, in theory, still know what happened before time was
reset. (In "All Hell Breaks Loose", when time was reset on Earth, the people
"down there" were unaffected. Stands to reason that the people "up there"
would not be affected either. I would not be at all surprised if this little
detail was overlooked though, given this shows track record.)

I hope they give us a damn good reason for making Brody a Whitelighter, but
I won't be surprised if the reason turns out to be crap. ( I am still
cringing over the whole "Sheridan got a blood sample from Piper's room"
excuse. Was this in the split second between the time she entered the
doorway and was flung across the room into a wall?)

[Spam Free]

Post by Red Wind
I hope they give us a damn good reason for making Brody a
Whitelighter, but I won't be surprised if the reason turns out to be
crap. ( I am still cringing over the whole "Sheridan got a blood
sample from Piper's room" excuse. Was this in the split second between
the time she entered the doorway and was flung across the room into a
wall?)

I thought the reference to getting the blood sample was from when they were
in the room at the end of the previous season...yes, no?

Mark

[Cardman]

Post by luvthistle1
Spoiler.........spoiler>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
.>.....
spoiler*******************************************************************************************************************************
I love Kerr Smith, as Agent Brody, when he first came on the show. I
also thought that he and Paige made a perfect couple...until that he
became so obsess with the avatars, that he doesn't seem to care for
anyone else, or about who he hurt in the process.

He seemed ok. Still, his intense Avatar hating does make him very
narrow minded.

Post by luvthistle1
In There's Something About Leo". Brody finds out that Leo is an avatar.
he doesn't want to talk about it, or anything he just want to kill Leo,
because Leo is an avatar ( did he think Paige was going to be o.k with
that? or did he care?)

He wanted to kill the other Avatars. He just said that he would kill
Leo instead if he did not summon the other Avatars.

Post by luvthistle1
The Brody knock out Paige, held a gun to Phoebe head , and threaten to
kill her,. than he tried to kill Leo....but since the whole thing was
revease..the Charmed ones will never know...

Just as well, when he would have been out of there in no time.

Post by luvthistle1
which is information Paige needed to know, before the incident in
Witchness Protection"..in which they found out that he put sheridan in
a coma. Note- Brody said he can take her out any time he want too,..but
how? what type of coma is she in? and drug induce coma, or an magic
induce coma?

Since Kyle Brody is not magical (IOO), then it seems obvious enough
that it is drug caused.

All this makes you wonder if he checked out her lunch box though?! ;-]

Post by luvthistle1
Than in "Ordinary Witches" Brody again, kills Leo,

I don't believe so. He tries, but the other Avatars stop him.

Post by luvthistle1
even after Paige
told him that Leo is not an threat to him, or anyone. again,

Well Kyle is all upset about their little flesh wound on mommy and
daddy. :-]

Post by luvthistle1
time is revease so that no one knows.

You must be reading up on the wrong episode. This one did involve time
travel though.

Post by luvthistle1
spoiler*********************
Brody finds out that the avatars did not kill his parents after all,
yet he still wants to kill avatars..

Apparently so.

Post by luvthistle1
but the charmed ones will never know that, because time is reset.

What the hell you been reading? :-]

They won't know because they were not in Kyle's apartment when he was
fingering the second Avatar killing potion with a determined look on
his face!

So all Paige and the other's believe is that Kyle now accepts that the
Avatars did not kill his parents.

Post by luvthistle1
Than in Extreme Makeover: World Edition. Brody works with the demon
Zankou to get rid of the avatars.

I am glad you had a spoiler warning.

Post by luvthistle1
he even use a potion he got from Zankou on Paige,

Crystal of paranoia.

Post by luvthistle1
(which speads to all of the charmed ones) to make them paranoid.

By touch alone.

Post by luvthistle1
Brody feels that killing all the demons is wrong (
althought he right, still).

The loss of Evil also means the loss of Good. Kyle does not wish to
lose the good.

You don't see much loss of Good in this episode...

Post by luvthistle1
but since he know it was the demons who
killed his parents, it would seem like he would wants to kill all the
demons?

Yes, it does seem very strange. The previous episode made it appear
more like the Avatars did kill his parents, where they just showed him
a false reality of celebrity demons doing it.

In fact it does not seem to fit together with the previous episode at
all well. There was a really good scene of Leo and the Elders in 7x11,
but in 7x12 you do not see the Elders at all.

And since it is like War between the Elders and the Avatars/TCOs now,
then what the hell are they all doing in hostile land of Magic School?

You could read that the Elders simply gave up and decided not to
defend "good", but that seems extremely unlikely.

Post by luvthistle1
he kills an avatar

Avatar Beta. The female Avatar.

Post by luvthistle1
and dies...

Kyle Brody dead. Another huge spoiler.

I am thinking that they could be asking a lot to have Rose do this
scene, but it is also a rare opportunity for her to show off just what
she can do.

Post by luvthistle1
new world.

Yes, it does seem Utopia enough.

A much better representation than with their ultra good world shown in
6x22/3 "Bad, Bad, World". That one was morally more evil than with the
evil reality.

Post by luvthistle1
the charmed ones are still not aware that Brody did anything wrong...

Paige knows. The Avatars know as well. So soon enough everyone will
know that Kyle killed Beta.

Post by luvthistle1
and to top it all off,
what do he get for putting Sheridan in a coma, knocking out his
girlfriend, threatening to kill Phoebe, and Killing Leo twice,

Well he is stiff as a board. Seems like justice enough for such a
revenge orientated person. :-]

Or used to be revenge orientated at is, when now he is simply weird.

That "Extreme Makeover World Addition" just seems to be going at this
big event with the wrong starting motivations. Having the Avatars been
Kyle's parent murders would make things much more understandable.

Post by luvthistle1
casting a spell/potion on the charmed ones,

Read "curse".

Post by luvthistle1
and working with demons?

Mutual goals. Even the Charmed Ones have done that before.

Post by luvthistle1
what do he gets?!

A nice slab of marble with his name carved in it. Not to mention a
nice 8ft by 3ft plot of land. :-]

Post by luvthistle1
......he gets to become a..say it with me.....he get to become.....
....A "WHITELIGHTER!"
"Carpe Demon'

Just where did you hear that? That is four episodes in the future and
so quite fresh.

Yes it does seem like an odd idea, when Whitelighters are supposed to
be quite caring people. Even Leo should have been stripped when he
went on his murder spree.

Still, maybe they granted him a free wish for helping take out an
Avatar, where he picked being a Whitelighter.

In fact Charmed's Whitelighters in general are not too respectful
group of people. Leo the murderer, bossy Natalie, two time loser Sam,
then now Kyle of the bloody revenge.

Post by luvthistle1
he didn't save the world, nor did he save the charmed one or the
elders...he just kill one avatar,

The enemy of my enemy is my friend. So the Elders see good enough
reason to reward him.

Post by luvthistle1
The charmed ones, or anyone would ever know how crazy obsess with
avatars he truely was,

Well Leo well knows. The other Avatars should know, where TCOs should
have an idea.

Post by luvthistle1
nor will they ever know all the wrong he done....
that time reset, really sucks.

Kyle was a freaky person. Now he is a dead freaky person. Just maybe
he will return as a freaky Whitelighter. If so, then he will be right
at home.

Cardman
http://www.cardman.com
http://www.cardman.co.uk

[luvthistle1]

....I think they made Brody a whitelighter to say you do not have to be
"perfect" , to become one, ..you just have to have done somthing
good....which I think is a set up for someone else we might see in the
future, who had became a whitelighter. so now I'm o.k with the hold
thing.... plus Brody finally admitted that he was a little crazy.